It's All About Nathan MacKinnon In The Consensus Top 50

Derek Zona
October 26 2012 04:08PM

Halifax Mooseheads Logo

When we last checked in on the 2013 NHL Draft rankings, it was all about Nathan MacKinnon.  The October rankings...haven't changed at all.  He's still the number one player on the list and it's not close.  Copper & Blue writer Alan Hull got to view MacKinnon in person in early October and though he thought MacKinnon had an off game, he did see the skill:

"He certainly showed that he does have high-level skills, though I didn't see anything on this night that I would classify as elite. Among his biggest assets, he has the ability to be strong on the puck and hold off defenders with his strength and he has some explosive speed when he wanted to show it, which unfortunately was not often enough on this night."

Hull's biggest criticism?  A lack of attention to defense.  Something that is nearly universal in young scoring centers:

As a centre, he needed to be down below the face-off dot much more often engaging in the team's defensive zone coverage. Instead, I found him to be staying too high, and at the first appearance of an opportunity for the Mooseheads to gain possession, he was gone...out towards the blue line and frequently beyond it hoping to lead the rush.

MacKinnon is one of three Mooseheads in the top 24 in this month's Consensus Rankings.  The sources for the consensus list are Bob McKenzie, Future Considerations, ISS, Corey Pronman of Hockey Prospectus, and The Scouting Report.

#   Pos   Name   DOB   HT   WT   L/R   Team   Move
1 F Nathan MacKinnon 9/1/1995 5'11 180 R Halifax Mooseheads 0
2 D Seth Jones 11/3/1994 6'3 205 R Portland Winterhawks 0
3 F Aleksander Barkov 9/2/1995 6'2 205 L Tappara 2
4 F Sean Monahan 10/12/1994 6'2 180 R Ottawa 67s -1
5 F Elias Lindholm 12/2/1994 6 183 R Brynas -1
6 D Rasmus Ristolainen 10/27/1994 6'3 210 R TPS Turku 1
7 D Ryan Pulock 10/6/1994 6 195 R Brandon Wheat Kings 4
8 F Hunter Shinkaruk 11/13/1994 5'10 170 L Medicine Hat Tigers -2
9 F Jonathan Drouin 3/27/1995 5'11 180 L Halifax Mooseheads 3
10 F Curtis Lazar 2/2/1995 6 190 R Edmonton Oil Kings 0
11 F Valeri Nichushkin 3/4/1995 6'3 180 R Chelyabinsk -2
12 F Andre Burakovsky 2/9/1995 6'1 175 L Malmo -4
13 F Adam Erne 4/20/1995 6 200 L Quebec Remparts 0
14 D Josh Morrissey 3/28/1995 6 185 L Prince Albert Raiders 3
15 D Nikita Zadorov 4/16/1995 6'4 205 L London Knights 1
16 F Kerby Rychel 10/7/1994 6'1 185 L Windsor Spitfires -2
17 D Robert Hagg 2/8/1995 6'2 201 L MODO -2
18 F J.T. Compher 4/8/1995 6 170 R USNDT 3
19 D Darnell Nurse 2/4/1995 6'4 185 L Soo Greyhounds 6
20 F Jacob De la Rose 5/20/1995 6'2 185 F Leksand -2
21 F Ryan Kujawinski 3/30/1995 6'2 180 L Kingston Frontenacs 3
22 F Anthony Duclair 7/26/1995 6 160 L Quebec Remparts -3
23 F Ryan Hartman 9/20/1994 5'11 185 R Plymouth Whalers 3
24 G Zach Fucale 5/28/1995 6 170 L Halifax Mooseheads -2
25 F Max Domi 3/2/1995 5'9 185 L London Knights -2
26 F Artturi Lehkonen 7/4/1995 5'10 163 L TPS Turku 4
27 F Bo Horvat 4/5/1995 6 195 L London Knights 7
28 F Hudson Fasching 7/28/1995 6'3 208 R USNDT -8
29 F Pavel Buchnevich 4/17/1995 6 165 l Almaz Cherepovets 0
30 D Ian McCoshen 8/5/1995 6'3 205 L Waterloo Blackhawks -2
31 F William Carrier 12/20/1994 6 195 L Cape Breton -4
32 D Madison Bowey 4/22/1995 6'1 195 R Kelowna Rockets -1
33 D Eric Roy 10/24/1994 6'3 190 L Brandon Wheat Kings 4
34 F Frederik Gauthier 4/26/1995 6'1 210 L Rimouski Oceanic N/A
35 D Steve Santini 3/7/1995 6'2 205 R USNDT 4
36 F Jason Dickinson 7/4/1995 6'2 179 L Guelph Storm N/A
37 F Stephen Harper 3/25/1995 6'2 202 L Erie Otters N/A
38 D Keaton Thompson 9/14/1995 6'1 170 L USNDT 8
39 D Mike Downing 5/19/1995 6'3 190 L Dubuque Fighting Saints N/A
40 D Jan Kostalek 2/17/1995 6 175 L Sparta Praha -5
41 D Will Butcher 1/6/1995 5'11 190 L USNDT -9
42 F Tyler Motte 3/10/1995 5'10 165 R USNDT -6
43 F Alex Forsberg 1/4/1995 5'9 170 L Prince George  -10
44 G Eric Comrie 7/6/1995 6'1 175 L Tri City Americans 6
45 F Connor Hurley 9/15/1995 6'1 175 L Edina High School 2
46 F Juuso Ikonen 1/3/1995 6'3 198 R Espoo Blues 6
47 D Samuel Morin 7/12/1995 6'5 184 L Rimouski Oceanic 17
48 F Lukas Wallmark 9/5/1995 5'10 175 L Skelleftea 12
49 F Markus Soberg 4/22/1995 6' 175 R Frolunda -11
50 F Sergei Tolchinsky 2/3/1995 5'7 150 L Soo Greyhounds 17

  • A note about a player not in the top 50: Anton Slepyshev.  He's an incredibly talented player, so much so that if there weren't concerns about him not wanting to come to North America he would have been a first round pick last year.  At this point, though, the talent far outweighs the risk of the player not coming over, and a team would have to be out of their minds to pass on him in the second round in June.  Corey Pronman had him in the top 20 for the June 2012 draft"Slepyshev is an above-average skater who is tremendously agile and is also able to get up to a notable top gear. When you combine his great agility with the fact he has high-end puck skills, he really is a nuisance to check. Slepyshev is very effective at dodging opponents and creating space for himself. I've seen times on penalty kills where he would dance around the opposing zone for 15-25 seconds because several opponents keep missing him. Slepyshev has a plus if not near that shot and he knows it, as he has a shoot-first mentality with the ability to score from way out."
  • The big gainers this month were defensemen Ryan Pulock from the Brandon Wheat Kings and Darnell Nurse from the Soo Greyhounds.  Pulock is small, but The Scouting Report likes his offensive game and his huge shot.  Nurse was compared to Chris Pronger at the Bantam Draft, but didn't perform like Pronger early on.  However, the 6'4" defender is playing with more aggression and scouts have noticed.  He's up six spots to #19.
  • There are three goalies ranked in the top 60, but only Halifax's Zach Fucale is ranked as a first-round talent.  Fucale is playing on a star-studded team, so he might not be the center of attention, but he's got Halifax on top of the league, and carries a .893 save percentage.  Fucale is undersized, so he may fall a bit more before all is said and done, but Halifax looks like a team that will compete for the Memorial Cup, so Fucale is going to get plenty of stage time.
  • The big loser this month was Hudson Fasching from the USNDT, already committed to Minnesota.  Fasching has all of the size and skill, but has fallen slightly because he's struggling to show the ability to get to the scoring areas and use his power forward build. 
E976572df3ea71edf6bafb00adc1c546
Avatar
#1 RexLibris
October 26 2012, 05:41PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
+1
0
props

Looks like a deep prospect group.

I love watching the various players rise and fall through the draft rankings as the year goes on. Seeing what can't-miss-kids move out of the first round and can be stolen in the second is always intriguing to me.

Definitely a good year to stock up on some additional 2nd round picks.

Avatar
#3 FastOil
October 26 2012, 10:34PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
+1
0
props

On board with that. The team is one quality centre away from stocked enough.

Avatar
#4 They're $hittie
October 27 2012, 04:18PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
+1
0
props

@FastOil

While I want Mckinnon, how would we pay all these guys. The teams with two dominant centers will not have the winger depth that the oilers do. Gagner at 3.5 and 50 points is fine, with the four top wingers we have.

Avatar
#5 RexLibris
October 28 2012, 09:33AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
+1
0
props
Derek Zona wrote:

I'm on the opposite side. It's the year to trade all seven picks plus for MacKinnon.

lol

Do you think that would work? How many teams would be willing to add to Edmonton's already stocked roster? I mean aside from the Islanders.

McKinnon is a phenomenal talent, but I have to wonder if the team could be well-served in the long-run by finding a Jonathan Toews-type player in the top ten (assuming that is where they draft). Someone like that might pair really well with the current crop of wingers and behind Nugent-Hopkins.

We'll see. I have two hopes this June: the Oilers in the top ten, the Flames outside of it. =)

Avatar
#6 FastOil
October 28 2012, 11:41AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
+1
0
props

Perhaps they can't. It depends on how you think a team is best built. For me I think strength at centre is more valuable than on the wing, so if it comes to pass I'd be happy losing a winger for an equally skilled centre.

I can't see Hemsky remaining an Oiler long term, so there's some room there. Maybe they'll trade him for Luongo ha ha.

Avatar
#7 The Oilers Shot Clock
October 28 2012, 02:11PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
+1
0
props

Lazar could be another Lander. I hope we get one of those big tall D-men, and it wouldnt bother me if rounds one and two were spent on it. Nurse and Morin would suit me fine. System would be chalk full of 6'3 and up defenseman. Throw enough of them against the wall and see who sticks. I dont mind the idea of rolling the dice on that Slepy kid either. Maybe him and Nail could be Russian peas and carrots.

Comments are closed for this article.