The Trouble With Drafting Goalies

Kent Wilson
December 26 2015 04:00PM

(This article was originally published on August 14, 2008 on my now defunct personal blog. It stands as perhaps my most seminal piece so I wanted to re-share it here. To some degree, it explains the goaltender market and why teams have generally moved away from drafting puck stoppers in the first round. I have edited it slightly to remove overly dated references.) 

During my look at Sutter's draft history as the Flames GM, I commented that I was surprised the club drafted two goalies in a single year (Keetley and Lalande in '05). That and the preponderance of goaltending prospects the organization (the two above plus McElhinney, Irving and James Spratt) has got me wondering about goalies recently, in particular the draft/develop part. 

I've come to the shaky but ever strengthening conclusion that drafting goaltenders is just about a complete waste of time.

Bear with me. 

Read Article | 12 Comments

Future Free Agent Profiles: Victor Hedman

Cam Lewis
December 26 2015 01:10PM

Steven Stamkos’ contract situation has been a huge soap opera all year in Tampa Bay. Does he want to stick around, or is he going to take the chance to bolt to Toronto and fulfill his childhood dream of playing for the Maple Leafs? Should they trade him, becoming younger and cheaper in the process, or keep him around for a playoff run, as they’re just a few months removed from the Stanley Cup Finals? What a headache. 

Thankfully the Lightning, once their franchise centre makes his decision this summer, things will quiet down and return to normal, right? Wrong. Along with Stamkos, Steve Yzerman is facing the task of coming up with new contracts for pretty much his entire team over the next couple of summers. The name at the top of that list is Victor Hedman, who’s established himself as one of the league’s best defencemen, and arguably Tampa’s most important player moving forward. 

Read Article | 1 Comments

The Roundup

Nation World HQ
December 25 2015 06:00AM

Screen Shot 2015-08-11 at 9.42.56 AM

A Canucks Christmas rap, Mike Babcock and Christmas come early, Johnny Gaudreau is very good at hockey, can the Oilers sign Steven Stamkos, World Junior previews, Justin Schultz, Dougie Hamilton, Jake Gardiner and more in the weeks Nation Roundup brought to you by DraftKings. Merry Christmas Nation!!

Read Article | 7 Comments

Helping Chevy Make Decisions Part 2: Isolating where the Jets struggle

Garret Hohl
December 24 2015 01:42PM

Winnipeg Jets General Manager Kevin Cheveldayoff faces some big decisions. 

The Jets currently sit tied for 2nd last in the Western Conference and last in the Central Division. Compounding their current struggles, the team is dealing with long-range uncertainty. They have two huge pending unrestricted free agents in Andrew Ladd and Dustin Byfuglien and restricted free agents Mark Scheifele and Jacob Trouba, two big pieces of Winnipeg's future, will be looking for significant raises this offseason.

With all that's on Chevy's plate this holiday season, we've decided to help him out. With this investigative series, we'll take a look on where the Jets are and where they could be.

In Part I we noted that the Jets' overall talent was not quite at the level of an NHL contender, especially as you moved toward the lower end of the roster. The Jets are, however, better than most bottom rung playoff teams (despite where their lowly current spot in the standings). In Part II we'll analyze which particular areas are afflicting the Jets at the moment, and try to quantify the extent of their issues.

Read Article | 4 Comments

2016 Draft-Eligibles to Watch at the World Juniors

Shawn Reis
December 23 2015 09:08AM

With the World Juniors right around the corner, it's about time we start sizing up some of the teams and some of the players.  Today we'll be taking a look not at the Leafs prospects playing in the tournament, but the players that could one day ultimately end up being Leafs prospects.  Let's take a look at the best players in this year's World Juniors eligible for the 2016 draft.

CANADA

Canada is bringing a young roster to the World Juniors this year.  And yet as young as the team is, there's only one player on the roster that's actually draft-eligible: Val d'Or's Julien Gauthier.  The consensus 7th-best player for the upcoming draft as of right now, there's a lot to like about Gauthier's game.  He's 6"4'.  He has 29 goals in 30 games played in the QMJHL so far this season.  He's got 109 shots on goal in those 30 games.  He's got a strong combination of a myriad of different skills: he gets around the ice well for his size, he can handle the puck, he can dish it off to a teammate if that's the right play to make, and yes, he can really wire it.  All of these factors combine to make Gauthier a likely top ten pick next June, and he'll probably be the second Canadian to have his named called at the draft, just after Sarnia's Jakob Chychrun, who was cut during Canada's selection camp process.

Read Article | 2 Comments